Is Divorce Worse Than Staying in a Toxic Marriage for Kids? The Emotional Truth Parents Need to Know
Category:
Many parents worry that divorce will harm their children permanently. That fear often drives couples to stay in toxic or emotionally unhealthy marriages. But are we protecting our children, or simply modeling dysfunction?
This article explores the psychological, emotional, and behavioral impacts of unhappy marriages vs. divorce, guided by therapeutic principles and real-world observations from a licensed expert.
Original Perspective: The Emotional Impact of Staying in a Broken Marriage
“Children need to learn what true love is. They deserve to be in a peaceful home, empty of angry, hostile emotions.” – Shauna Hoffman
Parents often feel that divorce will ruin their children’s lives forever, and because of this, stay in unhealthy and miserable marriages, “for the sake of the kids”. But the truth is that Children need to learn what true love is. They deserve to be in a peaceful home free of angry, hostile emotions. When a couple stays in an unhealthy marriage, you are teaching them that THIS IS WHAT MARRIAGE LOOKS LIKE. Often, the scars of living with unhappy parents are much worse than the scars of divorce. Children learn how to act in relationships by the models in their lives. If you are modeling that a marriage is bad communication, disrespect for your mate, and sacrificing your voice at all costs, then that is what they will choose for their marriage.
What Does Psychological Research Say?
Attachment Theory in Action
Children raised in homes full of unresolved conflict often form anxious or avoidant attachment styles. This can affect:
- Their future romantic relationships
- Emotional regulation
- Conflict resolution abilities
John Bowlby’s Attachment Theory reveals that children internalize emotional safety as the basis of lifelong mental health. Emotional chaos leads to insecurity, not resilience.
Modeling Dysfunction: What Are You Really Teaching Them?
I often have my clients ask me to give them the answer, leave, or stay! My answer to them is to make sure that they have done all that they can to save the marriage first. If it does not seem to be healing, you will know your answer. It is then that it becomes easier to do what is right for your family. If it is divorce, then one day you will be able to tell your children that you both TRIED! That is a much healthier lesson for them than suffering. In my practice, I have seen a myriad of emotions from the children of divorce, from anger, fear, and sadness to absolute relief! Yep! Relief. Relief that they do not have to listen to the fighting anymore. Relief that the tears and hostility are no longer in the house. But most importantly, relief that they no longer feel responsible for their parents’ happiness.
Long-Term Effects of Toxic Marriages on Children
Behavioral and Academic Impacts
- Poor concentration in school
- Withdrawal or aggression with peers
- Risk of anxiety disorders
- Bed-wetting, tantrums, and regressive behaviors in young children
A 2019 study by the American Psychological Association found that chronic parental conflict is more predictive of poor academic performance than parental separation itself.
Therapy First: Have You Explored Every Avenue?
Before you make any final decision, ensure you’ve tried comprehensive relationship healing tools.
Recommended Approaches:
- Gottman Method Couples Therapy
- Emotionally Focused Therapy (EFT)
- Family Systems Therapy
- Conflict Resolution Coaching
- Attachment-Based Parenting Counseling
“Trying” should be measurable, not emotional. Did you attempt professional intervention, structured communication, or neutral third-party facilitation?
Divorce Isn’t the End – It Can Be a New Beginning
Children are like barometers of all the emotions in the home. They soak up the way Mom is feeling that day, or the way Dad is talking that day. They know when a door is slammed, or when a parent yells at them for no reason that something is wrong. Sadly, the children bear the load. They carry it with them when they go to school. It shows in their attitudes towards their peers. But most importantly, it shows in their attitudes towards their self; i.e., their self-esteem. So in the end, if you have tried to save the marriage, and if you have evaluated all sides of staying or leaving, the words “FOR THE SAKE OF THE KIDS” will have new meaning.
The Power of Healthy Co-Parenting Post-Divorce
You can still provide stability, love, and security from two different homes.
Co-Parenting Best Practices:
- Maintain similar rules and routines
- Speak respectfully about the other parent
- Use co-parenting apps to manage communication
- Involve child therapists during transitions
- Avoid parental alienation at all costs
Research from the Journal of Family Psychology shows that consistent co-parenting routines reduce anxiety and improve school performance in children of divorced families.
Divorce vs. Staying in a Toxic Marriage: A Comparison
| Factor | Divorce (With Co-Parenting) | Staying in Toxic Marriage |
|---|---|---|
| Emotional Environment | Peaceful, structured | Unpredictable, hostile |
| Child Guilt Level | Reduced over time | Often elevated |
| Future Relationship Modeling | Healthy if managed well | Distorted by conflict |
| Attachment Style Outcome | Secure/adjusted | Anxious/avoidant |
FAQs
Should I stay in a bad marriage for the kids?
No, not always. If your home is filled with conflict or emotional detachment, children can be more harmed by what they witness than by the process of divorce.
What are signs my child is affected by my marriage?
Watch for changes in mood, withdrawal, school struggles, or fearfulness. These are often symptoms of emotional overload.
What therapy is best for struggling marriages?
The Gottman Method and Emotionally Focused Therapy (EFT) are research-backed approaches for rebuilding emotional bonds.
How do I talk to my child about divorce?
Be honest but age-appropriate. Emphasize love, consistency, and the fact that it’s not their fault.
Take Action: Do What’s Truly Best “For the Sake of the Kids”
If you’ve done the work to try and your marriage still isn’t healing, your child’s peace may come from separation, not suffering.
Shauna Hoffman is a Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist (LMFT) practicing in Santa Clarita, CA. She specializes in family dynamics, emotional trauma, and co-parenting success after divorce.
Call for a confidential consultation: (661) 714-5137
