Can a Parent Move Away with a Child? How to Contest Custody Relocation in Family Court

In family law, move-away cases involve legal and emotional challenges. These cases arise when one parent, post-divorce or separation, seeks to relocate the child to another city, state, or country, permanently or temporarily. Often, the relocation is driven by career opportunities, remarriage, financial concerns, or proximity to extended family.

The core challenge? The parent left behind risks losing consistent physical access to their child, while the relocating parent argues for continuity of care, stability, or safety.

Understanding these conflicts requires analyzing legal precedents, statutory obligations, and psychological dynamics.

Legal Basis: What is a Judicial Custody Order?

A judicial custody order is a binding decision by a family court judge. It determines:

• Legal custody (decision-making authority on education, healthcare, religion).
• Physical custody (residential arrangement).

Types include:

• Sole Custody: One parent is primarily responsible.
• Joint Custody: Shared responsibilities and time division.
• Split Custody: Siblings live with different parents.
• Temporary Orders: Issued during ongoing proceedings.

Importantly, move-away rules only apply if a custody order is already in place. If none exists, the situation is treated as an initial custody dispute, not a relocation modification.

Core Precedent Explanation: Burgess & Campos Cases

Burgess Case (1996)

“Where there is a judicial custody order in place, the custodial parent has a presumptive right to change the residence of the minor children so long as the removal would not be prejudicial to their rights and welfare.”

This 1996 California Supreme Court ruling created a strong presumption in favor of the custodial parent in relocation matters, placing the burden on the objecting parent to demonstrate detriment to the child.

In re Marriage of Campos (2003 DJDAR 5237)

In Campos, the trial court allowed the mother to relocate without a full hearing. However, the Court of Appeal reversed, asserting:

“The objecting parent is entitled to a hearing and the opportunity to present evidence of detriment to the child.”

This reinforced the importance of procedural fairness and evidentiary evaluation in move-away cases.

How Courts Evaluate Move-Away Requests

Judges must weigh the rights of both parents and the child’s welfare using a holistic, case-by-case approach. Common criteria include:

• The reason for the move: Is it for a legitimate purpose like employment or education, or driven by personal conflict?
• The existing parenting arrangement: Are both parents actively involved?
• The child’s age and preferences: Older children may have a stronger voice.
• The practical impact of the move on schooling, friendships, and routines.

These assessments are not binary but require careful intent, outcomes, and stability analysis.

Understanding Bad Faith, Detriment & Child’s Best Interests

Bad Faith

If the court detects that a move is designed to frustrate the other parent’s access, it may deny the request. Examples:

• Sudden or secretive relocation.
• Refusing alternative visitation schedules.
• Alienation behaviors.

Detriment to the Child

This refers to emotional, educational, or physical harm the child may suffer:

• Disruption of schooling.
• Social isolation.
• Loss of bond with the non-custodial parent.
• Relocation to an unstable or unsafe environment.

The objecting parent must prove that the move would cause such detriment and that a custody modification is essential to prevent it.

Psychological and Emotional Impact on Children

Children are emotionally vulnerable during major life changes. The absence of one parent due to relocation can lead to:

• Separation anxiety.
• Behavioral changes (withdrawal, aggression).
• Academic performance declines.
• Feelings of abandonment or guilt.

Psychologists often recommend transitional support:

• Therapy.
• Co-parenting coaching.
• Keeping routines consistent.
• Ensuring communication with both parents remains open.

Co-Parenting, Parenting Plans, and Virtual Visitation

Parenting plans are court-approved schedules that define how divorced or separated parents will share custody. In move-away situations, these plans often need to be revised.

Modern technology can ease the transition:

• Video calls (Zoom, FaceTime).
• Shared calendars (Google Calendar for custody days).
• Digital homework sharing.

Courts encourage “liberal communication” between the child and the non-relocating parent when distance becomes a barrier.

State Variability: Does Jurisdiction Matter?

Yes, and significantly.

The Burgess and Campos cases apply to California, but other states follow different standards:

• Some require proof of a substantial change in circumstances before a move is allowed.
• Others place more weight on joint parenting rights.
• States like New York and Texas impose stricter limitations on out-of-state moves.

Supplementary Legal Concepts: UCCJEA and Custody Modification

UCCJEA (Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction and Enforcement Act)

Adopted by 49 states, this law ensures that:

• One state holds exclusive jurisdiction over custody decisions.
• Prevents forum shopping by parents relocating for legal advantages.

Custody Modification

If a parent moves and the court finds detriment, it may modify the custody order:

• Primary custody may shift to the other parent.
• Visitations may be restructured to long, extended periods during school breaks.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Can a parent move a child out of state without the other parent’s consent?

Not legally, if there’s a custody order. Consent or a court modification is required.

What happens if my ex moves without telling me?

You can file a motion to enforce or modify custody. Courts may even order the return of the child.

What evidence do I need to block a move?

You must show that it would cause detriment to the child or is being done in bad faith.

Will the court listen to the child’s wishes?

Yes, particularly if the child is over 14 or deemed mature enough.

Can a move-away be temporary?

Yes, courts still consider the potential long-term impact and whether the move disrupts the parenting plan.

Final Reflections

Relocation custody disputes are emotionally charged, legally dense, and deeply personal. As family structures evolve and mobility increases, courts strive to balance parental freedom with children’s need for stability and love from both parents.

Understanding key precedents, your jurisdiction, and the potential psychological toll is all vital for either side of the dispute.

Need Personalized Help? Divorce Digest Is Here for You!

Whether you’re a custodial parent seeking a new start or a co-parent wanting to preserve your bond with your child, you don’t have to face it alone.

At Reape Rickett, we:

• Provide expert legal guidance tailored to your state’s laws.
• Help draft strong parenting plans.
• Offer consultations on move-away litigation.
• Support your journey toward amicable and child-focused resolutions.

Book a Free Legal Consultation

Visit Our Blog for More Family Law Insights

Contact a Family Law Specialist Now